In the past, concerns have been raised about the methodology of the PGR see some of the links in this post. It is unclear whether the current report has been improved in any of these regards. Comments on this from those in the know, including the current PGR editors, are welcome. The PGR is one of a few resources available to prospective graduate students in philosophy as they choose which programs to apply to and attend.
Further details about this will be forthcoming. Moreover, it is not obviously accurate: 1 plenty of people speak other languages in majority native Anglophone countries; 2 plenty of people speak English in majority non-native Anglophone countries, and indeed in these latter countries there are several Philosophy PhD programmes that work with English as their default language, but are not considered for ranking in the PGR.
Could be an interesting thing to see which programs out there offer a somewhat more grounded linguistic self-identification. For example, programs that include expertise on Deaf studies and philosophy of disability, CRT, indigenous philosophy, global philosophy ethics, epistemology , etc.
A bit like the question of what count as a foreign language entry in major entertainment industry awards. It in no way implies that only English is spoken in those countries nor that no one speaks English in other countries. My understanding is that there is a desire to keep the task of ranking schools to something close to manageable, and so there are some choices to be made. Where they should be made can be debated, of course. But at least in this case, that LMU is worth looking in to is noted, for just the reasons you suggest.
The PGR has always seemed to be a bit of inside baseball. As another data point: I am also a first gen student. I am also an international student from a non-English speaking country. I think every field — and especially every academic field — is ordered by a prestige hierarchy which may or may not be directly correlated to the quality of the program, placements, etc.
A public syndicate is much better than a private syndicate. Will a prefer a flat academic landscape with no syndicates? I think Yes. Given that — at least in the present — philosophy academia has syndicates, does PGR serve as a helpful guide? Very much so or at least very much so to at least one first-gen student. Your point is well taken!
I am so glad that the most recent rankings of a law professor at the University of Chicago has finally come out! I will now know that my alma mater sucks, and that comparative and Asian philosophy is junk. But, I expected nothing less. Why does the philosophical community even pay any attention to this claptrap, at all? Serious question.
Of the top-ranked programs, only one, Brown, actually has a leading Kant-scholar Guyer worth studying with. But he is close to retirement. Princeton has no Kant coverage. Princeton has been in the news recently only for linking Kant to critical race theory. This is traceable to the evaluators. In other words, the rankings are a grim exercise in nepotism. Not all of the referees are guilty of this, no doubt. If you think different people should be doing the evaluating, you could suggest names to the advisory board who are listed on the website.
It is a lot easier to complain, though, than to do something about what you perceive to be a problem. Not everyone listed on the advisory board is necessarily aware that this is the case, in my experience.
Hi David! That must be the friendliest call for a retraction that I have ever seen. It was written by a fellow brit, Alastair, so factor in passive aggressive politeness as appropriate. FWIW, this is a legitimate question rather than a complaint. Find out more. Why choose Canada?
Apart from the fact that Canadian Institutions are known for providing consistently high-quality education , Canada offers : Internationally recognised degrees.
Globally competitive state-of-the-art facilities. High graduate employability rates. Post-study work options as you can stay and work for up to 3 years. Culturally diverse experience for international students. How much does it cost to do PhD in Canada? Check out more on the cost of study and living in Canada How to choose the right university in Canada? To choose the perfect place for your study, you need to consider some important factors, such as: Program availability University ranking Faculty and staff reputation Research facilities Scholarships and funding options offered by the university Graduate employability rate Tuition fees Location PhD requirements in Canada PhD admission requirements in Canada vary based on the university and the field of study.
Read more about Canada student visa Kick start your education journey to Canada! Recommended articles. Masters in Canada Check out all info about universities admission requirements and costs of masters in Canada. Study abroad intakes in Canada Canadian universities and colleges offer three major intakes for students - fall, winter and summer.
International students with a PhD in Canada can avail of post-study work visa schemes. All details related to a PhD in Canada, such as top universities in Canada for PhD, admission requirements, fees, and scholarships in Canada for international students are discussed.
Canada has nearly research institutions offering doctoral degrees to both domestic and international students. These PhD programs in Canada are offered through dedicated graduate schools and colleges under the respective Canadian universities. Both public and private Canadian universities offer PhD programs in Canada to international students. International students in Canada pursuing PhD programs in Canada gain the opportunity to work with leading researchers and avail of top-quality research facilities and opportunities.
International students are also eligible for a Canadian work visa post-study in Canada. Online PhD in Canada is offered under various disciplines such as business administration, social sciences, etc.
Listed below are some of the reasons for international students to pursue a PhD in Canada:. PhD programs typically require students to pursue a full-time course for a minimum of three years, but it is often found that students require much more time to do their research and complete their degrees. Usually a PhD program in Canada gets completed within a maximum duration of of six years. The PhD is generally completed under the supervision of one or more academic supervisors in Canada.
Students need to submit a substantial doctoral thesis at the end of the course. The thesis is then reviewed and evaluated by a set of examiners. Additionally, you may be required to prepare a presentation to explain your research to the committee during your PhD oral defense.
Your overall performance and the quality of your thesis play a major role in obtaining a PhD degree in Canada. The admission requirements for international students to study PhD in Canada varies based on the program and the Canadian university. A PhD program in Canada takes up to years to complete. In Canada, the process for applying for a PhD may differ from one university to another. However, the common admission requirements of PhD offering universities in Canada remain the same.
Let us look at the step-by-step process of obtaining PhD admission in Canada:. You have the option to choose structured or open PhD programs in Canada.
In a Structured PhD, the research outline is determined by the university. In an Open PhD, you must propose and outline your own research project. Both courses require students to identify a supervisor who will guide them throughout the process.
In addition to your application, some universities will require a letter of support from your supervisor. If you have decided to pursue an open PhD in Canada, you must submit a research proposal outlining your project and its significance in the present. The research proposal must comply with the research guidelines set by your chosen university. Fill out the online application form of the university of your choice, pay the application fees, and attach the important documents.
0コメント